Motivated
God’s faithfulness gives us promises we can trust. It does not give us unrestricted knowledge of what will replace a lost opportunity or how an unwelcome event will develop. Encouragement becomes unreliable when it presents the future we hope for as something God has guaranteed.
Jeremiah 29 provides a particularly uncomfortable example because the famous promise of “a future and a hope” did not arrive in a vacuum. The exiles in Babylon had already heard a much more attractive message. In the previous chapter, the prophet Hananiah announced in the name of the Lord that Babylon’s yoke had been broken. Within two years, he said, the temple vessels would return and the exiles would come home. This was not secular optimism with God added afterward. Yahweh himself was presented as the one who would bring about the reversal.
Jeremiah even wanted Hananiah’s words to be true. “Amen! May Yahweh do so,” he replied. Returning home was not an improper desire. The problem was that God had not promised what Hananiah claimed he had promised.
Jeremiah’s message to the exiles was considerably less exciting. Build houses, plant gardens, marry and have children. Seek the welfare of Babylon and pray for it. Do not listen to the prophets who are promising otherwise, because the exile will last seventy years. Only in that setting does Jeremiah tell them that God knows the plans he has for them, plans for peace and not evil, to give them a future and a hope.
Both prophets invoked God and spoke about Israel’s future. Hananiah announced the desirable outcome the exiles understandably wanted and attributed it to Yahweh. Jeremiah allowed God’s actual word to define hope, even when that meant telling the exilic community that restoration would not come for seventy years and that many hearing the promise would spend the rest of their lives in Babylon.
Jeremiah 29:11 is therefore not less encouraging when read in context. It is a promise to the exilic community within God’s declared purpose to restore his people after seventy years. Its assurance does not depend upon every individual exile seeing an immediate reversal. Israel’s confidence rests on God’s faithfulness to what he has actually said.
Philippians 4:13 presents the problem from another direction. “I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me” sounds unmistakably Christian because Christ is explicitly the source of Paul’s strength. Yet the verse can still be made to serve a motivational understanding of what that strength is for.
Read by itself, “all things” is remarkably easy to fill with our ambitions. The difficult goal becomes something I can accomplish through Christ. The obstacle becomes something I can overcome through Christ. The future I want becomes attainable because Christ will supply what I lack. Christ remains essential to the claim, but did Scripture determine the outcome, or did we supply the outcome and ask Christ for the strength to reach it?
Paul does not leave the immediate referent of “all things” undefined. He has just explained that he has learned to be content whatever his circumstances. He knows how to be brought low and how to abound, what it is to be full and hungry, to have abundance and to suffer need. These conditions frame the claim that follows. His ability to remain content does not depend upon which circumstance he occupies; he can face either through the one who strengthens him.
That changes the shape of the encouragement considerably. Paul is not presenting Christ’s strength as a means of escaping need and reaching abundance. Christ strengthens him in both. Hunger does not cease to be hunger, and imprisonment does not become freedom simply because Paul belongs to Christ. Neither condition determines whether he can remain content and faithful.
This is more than correcting the misuse of a popular verse. It shows what happens when Scripture is permitted to define the end rather than merely provide the means of reaching one we have already chosen. The motivational reading makes accomplishment the desired result and Christ the power by which it becomes possible. Paul describes Christ’s strength as sufficient for faithfulness even when the preferable circumstance never arrives.
The setting of the letter makes the distinction harder to miss. Paul writes from imprisonment. He certainly has preferences about what happens next and hopes to see the Philippians again. Christianity does not require indifference to our circumstances or the pretence that every possible outcome is equally desirable. Yet earlier in the letter Paul can contemplate his own death and say that Christ will be magnified in his body “whether by life or by death.” Release would not prove Christ faithful, and continued imprisonment or death would not prove him unfaithful.
Jeremiah warns us against turning a future we desire into one God has promised. Philippians goes further: Scripture may refuse our definition of victory altogether. Christian hope does not merely give us a more powerful means of reaching the same destinations everyone else desires. Sometimes it changes the destination.
If Scripture does not promise that every setback is preparation for advancement, every closed door will lead to a better one or every difficult season will soon end, Christian encouragement might initially sound rather bleak. We have removed many familiar assurances without yet explaining what remains. What remains is the substance of Christian hope.
The New Testament does not encourage suffering believers by pretending that their suffering must soon give way to improved circumstances. Its confidence rests on events that have already happened and promises God has actually made. Christ has died and risen. Those who belong to him have been reconciled to God. Death itself will be defeated, the dead will be raised, and creation will finally be made new. Those truths do not depend upon what happens next Tuesday.
That is why Paul can describe himself and his companions as pressed, perplexed, pursued and struck down while insisting that they are not crushed, driven to despair, forsaken or destroyed. His explanation is not that each affliction will shortly disappear. He points instead to the resurrection: the one who raised the Lord Jesus will also raise those who belong to him. Romans 8 follows the same pattern. Creation groans, Christians groan, and weakness remains real enough that sometimes we do not even know what we ought to pray. Yet Paul reaches extraordinary confidence because none of these things can separate those who are in Christ from the love of God.
This kind of encouragement can survive circumstances becoming worse. That does not mean Christians should become suspicious of good things or reluctant to ask for them. We pray for the sick because healing is good, for provision because need is real, for reconciliation because broken relationships matter, and for deliverance because Scripture does not require us to enjoy suffering.
Paul demonstrates this when he describes his thorn in the flesh. Three times he pleads with the Lord for it to leave him. The answer is not the one he requested: “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” The significance is not merely that God said no. Paul asked for the weakness to be removed; Christ gave him a promise of sufficient grace within it. The unwanted circumstance could remain without making the promise false.
That gives Christian encouragement an honesty motivational encouragement cannot always afford. We do not have to tell someone grieving that God is about to replace what was lost, someone facing illness that healing is just ahead, or someone whose plans have collapsed that a better opportunity must be waiting nearby. Circumstances may change dramatically; they may not. We are not required to know.
We can instead say what Christianity gives us authority to say: God has reconciled sinners to himself through Christ; Christ has been raised from the dead; those who belong to him will be raised with him; suffering cannot separate them from the love of God; and death cannot have the final word. Christian hope does not require us to turn uncertainty into promises. It allows us to acknowledge uncertainty precisely because its central promises are secure.

